The challenge
During Black Friday, the client faced three key challenges that significantly limited performance and profitability.
- Skyrocketing nCAC (new Customer Acquisition Cost) during peak season
Historical data revealed that acquiring new customers during Black Friday had become too expensive to sustain. Competing in a market where major players significantly increase their budgets during the season drove up CPCs and CPMs, meaning that maintaining previous performance levels required progressively higher spend, making the strategy less efficient and sustainable over time.
- Ineffective past promotional structure
Their previous Black Friday offer (a flat 20% discount reserved for subscribers) ran for seven consecutive days but failed to create urgency or differentiation. As a premium brand, offering deep discounts would have undermined their luxury positioning, leaving them with little room to generate excitement while maintaining brand value.
- Minimal profitability
Despite consistent sales volume, the brand registered little to no profit in previous years. This required a meticulous focus on margin optimization and cost control, ensuring that every campaign decision contributed to sustainable, profitable growth rather than short-term revenue spikes.
Our solution
To address the skyrocketing nCAC, we shifted focus from acquiring new customers to nurturing existing ones, encouraging them to purchase during the Black Friday season. This required a revision of the media plan throughout the year, with a strategic reduction of investment during the peak period. Rather than competing directly with larger players, we optimized spend by 42% and targeted audiences with higher conversion likelihood. This approach maximized Net Profit while controlling costs, reserving new customer acquisition for less competitive periods.
To address the ineffective past promotional structure, we redesigned the Black Friday offer into multiple promo waves, testing a mix of BOGO (Buy One, Get One) mechanics and flat discounts with tiered thresholds. Thresholds for receiving free products or discounts were based on the AOV (Average Order Value) of existing customers, ensuring relevance and achievable targets.
Each promotion was carefully designed to generate urgency and perceived value without compromising the brand’s luxury positioning:
- Promo 1: Free product for a standard threshold, running for one week
- Promo 2: Free side product at a lower threshold, and two side products at a higher threshold, also lasting one week
- Promo 3: Free travel-size of the purchased product, available for one week
- Promo 4: Flash sale with a flat 15% off the entire catalog, running for 3 days
Free products were selected based on inventory needs and customer appeal, guaranteeing that every offer felt valuable, relevant, and aligned with the brand’s premium image.
To address minimal profitability, we adjusted budget allocation to focus on the most profitable areas. Spend on awareness and acquisition was reduced, while investment in remarketing and conversion activities was increased by 70%, leveraging prior heavy investment in acquisition to effectively convert those audiences.
From a technical standpoint, we updated ad campaigns across all managed channels to ensure seamless alignment with the Black Friday strategy. Given the multiple BOGO promotions running, we focused our copywriting efforts on testing two creative angles:
- The tangible benefits customers could gain from the product.
- The value of the free product(s) included in the promotion.
This allowed us to identify which approach resonated best and whether results varied significantly across the three target markets.
Collaboration was key. We worked closely with the client’s marketing team to receive all promotional assets well in advance, starting our Black Friday planning three months prior to ensure everything was ready ahead of the peak season.
Behind the scenes, all activities were carefully pre-scheduled. We added holiday-specific ads to existing campaigns and automated their activation and deactivation according to each promo wave. Given the account’s compact structure, we intentionally avoided creating new campaigns to prevent extended learning phases, especially in such a high-cost, competitive period.
To further enhance visibility and streamline execution, we implemented:
- Google Merchant Center Promotions, customized to reflect subscriber-only offers. We clearly detailed the shopper incentive, minimum purchase requirement, and eligibility criteria to drive engagement even without displaying a promo code.
- Google Sitelinks, used strategically to highlight each promotional wave directly in the search results, giving users more entry points and reinforcing urgency.
- Google Promotion Assets for the flash sale, since these were only applicable to monetary or percentage-based discounts, helping us occupy more SERP space during peak demand.
- Meta Ads updates, where we refreshed creatives within both acquisition and remarketing campaigns, testing benefit-led and value-led messaging to identify which approach resonated best across markets.
- Microsoft Ads synchronization, ensuring full cross-platform consistency and extended reach while maintaining the same strategic message across all channels.
- Automation setup, leveraging scheduled start and end dates, automated rules, and shopping sales features to minimize manual work, prevent last-minute errors, and ensure each promotion went live exactly as planned.
Once the setup was live, we continuously monitored and optimized performance in real-time, ensuring promotions activated and paused as planned, verifying links and on-site information, monitoring feed health and inventory levels, and adjusting bids and budgets to capitalize on strong-performing areas. We also stayed in close contact with the client to accommodate any last-minute updates or strategic shifts seamlessly.
By combining budget efficiency, tiered high-value promotions, and technical optimizations, we created a strategy that maintained the brand’s luxury positioning, generated urgency, and significantly improved overall profitability without relying on aggressive discounting or unsustainable acquisition spend.
The results
The new Black Friday strategy delivered a remarkable turnaround, transforming what had previously been a low-profit period into the most profitable of the year.
By shifting focus from sales growth to profitability, optimizing promo structures, and tailoring offers by market, the results speak for themselves: the brand achieved a +3541% increase in Net Profit, jumping from £223.77 to £8,148, while Net Margin soared from 0.74% to 27.85% (+3644%). Despite a slight decrease in Orders (-6%) and Revenue (-2.7%), overall profitability per order grew exponentially, with Average Net Profit rising from £0.56 to £21.5 (+3772%).
All this was achieved while reducing ad spend by 41.7%, confirming that smarter budgeting and value-driven promotions could outperform aggressive discounting.
Performance varied across markets, providing valuable insights into regional consumer behavior:
- US: Promo 3, offering a free travel-size of the purchased product, resonated exceptionally well with US users. This approach created a higher-value perception, as customers clearly recognized the tangible benefit of receiving an additional product rather than a simple discount. In this market, value-focused messaging outperformed benefit-focused messaging.
- Italy: Promo 1, which offered a free full-size product for a standard threshold, emerged as the top performer. Italian users responded strongly to benefit-led messaging, appreciating the opportunity to receive a full-size product for the same amount they would normally spend.
- UK: Promo 2, providing a free side product at a lower threshold and two side products at a higher threshold, achieved exceptional daily profitability despite a relatively lower investment. Users particularly valued the double free gift, which reinforced the perception of tangible value. The final Flash Sale, although shorter in duration, delivered the highest profit in the shortest time, confirming that monetary discounts effectively drive urgency and conversions in this market. Here, benefit-focused creatives performed best.
Through careful planning, creative testing, and data-led optimization, this strategy not only preserved the brand’s luxury positioning but also proved that profitability and premium branding can coexist, even during Black Friday.